Monday, April 21, 2008

MOMS RISING


The majority of commentators with something to say about bitterness in the Rustbelt, including me, have focused on gun-toting, beer swilling, bowling white men. But as we have seen in past primaries, boomer women, especially white, working-class women, have consistently pulled the lever for Hillary. Is this a version of identity politics? Perhaps, but I think there’s something deeper and more interesting going on. It has to do with feminism, its history, and our misunderstandings of it.

Since the 1960s, the right has labeled feminism in extreme terms. Feminists are man-hating and anti-feminine. They are deeply anti-family. They are “Feminazis,” ready to castrate any dissenting man in service of their elitist agenda. The assumption that feminists are anti-male, always radical, and elitist pervades popular culture and shapes the views of even my most liberal students. Over the past few weeks, I have been teaching about the transformations of women, family, gender, and sexuality in mid-twentieth century America. These weeks generate some of the most revealing discussions of the semester. Most of my students are nominally liberal products of privileged suburban households. They see feminism as inherently suspect. Their frames come largely from the political right. Most of my undergraduate women are deathly afraid to be labeled feminist lest they appear to be hirsute, unattractive, castrating lesbians to their male classmates. Most student men fear that self-identified feminists will be sanctimonious and preachy, unappealing sexual partners, and unfit mothers.

Our misunderstanding of feminism (which has analogies in our misunderstandings of the student left and black power) is the result of the media fixation on small groups of theatrical activists and the exploitation of those images by the right. But as Rutgers historian Dorothy Sue Cobble has argued in her important book, The Other Women's Movement, mid-twentieth century feminism was not solely or even primarily the creation of elite women. It differed in important ways from the clichéd accounts of feminism that shape our popular histories of the 1960s. Cobble chronicles an important and largely unknown story of working-class feminism. These feminists defined their struggle primarily in economic, not cultural terms. They represented blue and pink-collar women who, by the mid-twentieth century, were entering the paid workforce in increasing numbers, despite the pervasive rhetoric about the normative family headed by male breadwinners. These women were not, for the most part, in the paid labor market because it offered an escape from what Betty Friedan hyperbolically called the “comfortable concentration camp” of the suburban home. They were working because they had to.

The history of efforts to improve the economic conditions for working women, largely led by female unionists, needs to be foregrounded in our histories of the women’s movement. Historians and journalists spill much more ink on the protests at the 1968 Miss America Pageant, where radical protestors dumped girdles, false eyelashes, and copies of Playboy into a "Freedom Trash Can" before crowning a sheep as Miss America. We (erroneously) describe feminists as “bra burners” rather than telling the histories of waitresses and department store workers who organized unions and the women who used Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act as a tool for fighting against workplace discrimination on the basis of sex. Most feminists and feminist-sympathetic women in the late 1960s and 1970s were not burning their bras. They were getting up at 6 in the morning and putting on their bras and the rest of their work uniforms before making breakfast, packing their children’s lunchboxes, and then heading to work themselves, usually to insecure, underpaid “pink collar” jobs.

For these women that feminism really mattered. Against the odds, working-class feminists raised their wages and undermined sexist hiring practices, even if both victories were incomplete. Working-class feminists demanded better benefits and affordable child care and fought for family-friendly workplace policies. The feminist workplace revolution is still unfinished. And in fundamental respects it has been rolled back in the last two decades by biparisan indifference to the issues that matter most for ordinary working people, male and female alike.

Blue-collar and pink-collar women experienced the promise of feminism and its limitations. Today they have real reason to be bitter. In most states, family leave policies are still appalling, day care is expensive, and working women's wages are stagnant. Women are disproportionately represented in the ranks of part-time and contingent workers, both sectors of the labor market that are volatile and insecure.

This is a working world that is largely invisible to the young and to the privileged. And I think it helps to explain why so many older women gravitate toward Hillary Clinton. Whether Clinton will actually enact policies that will benefit these women is very much an open question. I’m doubtful. Welfare reform, with its mandatory work requirements, is not very family friendly. It’s a Clinton legacy. The Clintons supported a weak family leave policy, one of the worst in the industrialized west. Working women and men deserve better. Most workplaces are still far from family-friendly, especially in companies like Wal-Mart, on whose board of directors Hillary has served.

If Barack Obama wants to expand his base in blue-collar America, it’s time for him to take off his bowling shoes. Rather than hanging out with men in blue-collar bars, he needs to reach out to middle-aged, working-class women who are the backbone of the expanding service sector, who dominate employment in the now-struggling retail sector, and who are the underpaid care workers who take care of the sick and elderly while usually returning home to take care of their own aging parents or children or both. Their votes will really matter in November, given the persistent gender gap in voting between Democrats and Republicans. It is folly to ignore these struggling working women. Their lives are a reminder of feminism’s unfinished business. Their continued economic insecurity is a reminder of the failure of our public policies. Women, carework, and workplace rights should not be a fringe issue. They matter to us all.

32 comments:

La Lubu said...

Great post. Great blog, in fact. I can already tell I'll be stopping here more often!

Lily Dustbin said...

Very insightful post, you've given me much to think about.

AnnM said...

I've heard third-hand (a close friend who knows a former Clinton White House staffer) that Bill Clinton's biggest legislative regret is signing the welfare reform bill, that he did it because he thought it was the will of the body politic (supported by the American people) and it would reduce his power if he vetoed it.

I suspect approval of that legislation doesn't predict Hillary Clinton's approach to working women's needs very well.

human said...

Wow. Well done!

The Stute Fish said...

*bookmarks*

Excellent post. Will direct women who protest that they are not feminists here from now on, as well as to Tomato Nation's "Yes, You Are."

Hanna-Kaisa said...

as to the conversations with your students, this is really interesting too:

http://bitchphd.blogspot.com/2008/04/collectives_23.html

Tom S said...

Thanks, Hanna-Kaisa. Great post and set of comments for those of us who struggle with our students' issues with feminism. BTW, your post cut off the full link. Click here for Bitch Ph.D.'s discussion of feminism in the classroom.

Anonymous said...

Have you heared about 9Dragons which you need use Entropiauniverse ped to play, and you can also borrow Entropia Universe Gold from other players? But you can Buy Entropia Universe Gold, or you will lose the choice if you do not have Entropia Universe Money. If you get cheap Entropiauniverse ped, you can continue this game.
Have you heared about 9Dragons which you need use kal geons to play, and you can also borrow kal gold from other players? But you can buy kal online geons, or you will lose the choice if you do not have kal online gold. If you get kalonline Geons, you can continue this game.

Anonymous said...

I always heard something from my neighbor that he sometimes goes to the internet bar to play the game which will use him some Pirates of the Burning Sea Gold, he usually can win a lot of potbs gold, then he let his friends all have some potbs Doubloon, his friends thank him very much for introducing them the potbs money, they usually buy potbs Doubloon together.
I am so happy to get some ro zeny and the ragnarok zeny is given by my close friend who tells me that the iro zeny is the basis to enter into the game. Therefore, I should cheap zeny with the spare money and I gain some ragnarok online zeny from other players.

http://www.wholesale-brands.com said...

http://www.wholesale-China Wholesale Camera and Camcorder wholesale Camera and CamcorderChina wholesale Camcorders wholesale CamcordersChina wholesale Digital Cameras wholesale Digital CamerasChina wholesale Cell Phone wholesale Cell PhoneChina wholesale Apple Phones wholesale Apple PhoneChina wholesale LG Phones wholesale LG PhoneChina wholesale Motorola Phones wholesale Motorola PhonesChina wholesale Nokia Phones wholesale Nokia PhoneChina wholesale Philips Phones wholesale Philips PhonesChina wholesale Samsung Phones wholesale Samsung PhoneChina wholesale Sony Ericsson Phones wholesale Sony Ericsson PhonesChina wholesale DJ Equipment wholesale DJ EquipmentChina wholesale Games Console wholesale Games ConsolePlayStation 3" wholesale PlayStation 3


China wholesale GPS | wholesale Brand GPS direct from China" wholesale GPSChina wholesale Garmin GPS | wholesale Brand Garmin GPS direct from China" wholesale

Garmin
China wholesale Magellan GPS | wholesale Brand Magellan GPS direct from China" wholesale MagellanChina wholesale Navigon GPS | wholesale Brand Navigon GPS direct from China" wholesale NavigonChina wholesale TomTom GPS | wholesale Brand TomTom GPS direct from China" wholesale TomTomChina wholesale Laptops, Notebooks | wholesale Brand Laptops direct from China" wholesale Laptops, NotebooksChina wholesale Acer Laptops | wholesale Brand Acer Laptops direct from China" wholesale Acer LaptopsChina wholesale Apple Laptops | wholesale Brand Apple Laptops direct from China" wholesale Apple LaptopsChina wholesale Asus Laptops | wholesale Brand Asus Laptops direct from China" wholesale Asus LaptopsChina wholesale Dell Laptops | wholesale Brand Dell Laptops

direct from China" wholesale Dell LaptopsChina wholesale Fujitsu Laptops |

wholesale Brand Fujitsu Laptops direct from China" wholesale Fujitsu

Laptops
China wholesale Gateway Laptops | wholesale Brand Gateway Laptops direct from China" wholesale Gateway LaptopsChina wholesale HP Laptops | wholesale Brand HP Laptops direct from China" wholesale HP LaptopsChina wholesale Lenovo Laptops | wholesale Brand Lenovo Laptops direct from China" wholesale Lenovo Laptops

--------------------------

China wholesale MSI Laptops | wholesale Brand MSI Laptops direct from China" wholesale

MSI Laptops
China wholesale Panasonic Laptops | wholesale Brand Panasonic Laptops direct from China" wholesale Panasonic LaptopsChina wholesale Samsung Laptops | wholesale Brand Samsung Laptops direct from China" wholesale Samsung LaptopsChina wholesale Sony Laptops | wholesale Brand Sony

Laptops direct from China" wholesale Sony LaptopsChina wholesale Toshiba Laptops |

wholesale Brand Toshiba Laptops direct from Chin" wholesale Toshiba LaptopsChina Wholesale TVs HDTVs | wholesale Brand TVs HDTVs direct from China" wholesale TVs

HDTVs
China wholesale Coby HDTVs | wholesale Brand Coby HDTVs direct from China" wholesale Coby

HDTVs
China wholesale Epson HDTVs | wholesale Brand Epson HDTVs direct from China" wholesale Epson HDTVsChina wholesale Haier HDTVs | wholesale Brand Haier HDTVs direct from China" wholesale Haier HDTVsChina wholesale Hitachi HDTVs | wholesale Brand Hitachi HDTVs direct from China" wholesale Hitachi HDTVsChina wholesale JVC HDTVs | wholesale Brand JVC HDTVs direct

from China" wholesale JVC HDTVsChina wholesale LG HDTVs | wholesale Brand LG HDTVs

direct from China" wholesale LG HDTVsChina wholesale Magnavox HDTVs | wholesale Brand

Magnavox HDTVs direct from China" wholesale Magnavox HDTVsChina wholesale

Mitsubishi HDTVs | wholesale Brand Mitsubishi HDTVs direct from China" wholesale

Mitsubishi HDTVs

----------------------------

China wholesale Optoma HDTVs | wholesale Brand Optoma HDTVs direct from China wholesale Optoma HDTVsChina wholesale Panasonic HDTVs | wholesale Brand Panasonic HDTVs direct from China wholesale Panasonic HDTVsChina wholesale Philips HDTVs | wholesale Brand Philips HDTVs direct from China wholesale Philips HDTVsChina wholesale Pioneer HDTVs | wholesale Brand Pioneer HDTVs direct from China wholesale Pioneer HDTVsChina wholesale Samsung HDTVs | wholesale Brand Samsung HDTVs direct from China wholesale Samsung HDTVsChina wholesale Sharp HDTVs | wholesale Brand Sharp HDTVs direct from China  wholesale Sharp HDTVsChina wholesale Sony HDTVs | wholesale Brand Sony HDTVs direct from China  wholesale Sony HDTVsChina wholesale Sylvania HDTVs | wholesale Brand Sylvania HDTVs direct from China  wholesale Sylvania HDTVsChina wholesale Toshiba HDTVs | wholesale Brand Toshiba HDTVs direct from China
wholesale Toshiba HDTVsChina wholesale ViewSonic HDTVs | wholesale Brand ViewSonic HDTVs direct from China  wholesale ViewSonic HDTVsbrands.com

Anonymous said...

I am grateful to you for this great content

araç sorgulama
sorgulama
ehliyet
açıköğretim
bağkur sorgulama
ssk sorgulama
emekli sandığı
cinsellik
radyo dinle
korku
evlilik
hikaye
gazeteler

Unknown said...

No matter what product you purchase from us north face jacketsWe are offering you a wide range ofnorth face outletquestion,Some color combinations seem to never get old north face outerwearBut within the same community north face coatsbecause it features just the right amount of north face uk,look at another good paoduct such as Dior totes,A little of these are given below.ugg bootswas a very well-known French fashionable boot
cheap ugg boots,because of the wisdom of brilliant featuresdiscount ugg boots,which you are buying is unique and original classic ugg boots,When possible, they obtain materials from domestic suppliers ugg classic tall boots,which makes it exclusive and unique

ai said...

moncler
discout moncler jackets
moncler coats
moncler vest
moncler outlet
moncler Polo t shirt
cheap five finger shoes

Unknown said...

Teenagers in a track adidas tennis shoes can go through shoes rate discount adidas sneakers teenage runner well knows that newest adidas shoes 2010 to wear the right shoes discount moncler outlet any cross country among world cheap adidas shoes especially important to the sportsman wholesale adidas shoes a young person growing up adidas shoes outlet Not only do they want to discount moncler t-shirt grow out of their shoes cheap jordan shoes but shape of their feet changes new jordan shoes which means every time we new jordan shoes the time comes to get air jordan 2010 a new pair of shoes eveyone discount jordan shoes a good choice to get jumpman23 it with a high material Jordan ajf shoes that breathes easily on random Newest Timberland shoes 2010 They should be extended runs cheap Nike shox shoes give enough support to athlets discount brand shoes especially around the ankles area cheap Nike Dunk shoes to avoid injury your ankles AIR MAX shoes outlet when you make your trip 2010 New GHD something in store possible fit Benefit GHD his is also the way to

buy vps said...

Amazing article! It realty helped me to open up my eyes. Thanks for publishing and I'm looking forward to your new posts.
Mark B. from VpsWebServer
Visit us and learn all about windows vps.

Unknown said...

The christian louboutin store was designed for the ladies. Since the pumps was born, the ladies life become colorful. The christian louboutin evening pumps are the god's masterwork. Who invited thechristian louboutin pumps? Seldom people knew, but I think every lady would be grateful for him. Among the countless pumps, the christian louboutin peep toe is the most outstanding ones. The elegant pattern, the delicate style all mold the ladies perfect leg profile. Flowers in the spring of 2011 creeping, up from hair to clothes continue to footwear, have had a brilliant up. In such a glamor, spring and summer flowers now here. Romance is a woman's mood, exquisite flowers just right of expression in our gestures, the woman, how can we not love the romantic temperament so that they distributed the flowers do? 2011 flowers bloom will enjoy different poses! The Christian Louboutin 2011 Sandals also can adds the hright of the ladies, it bring surprise to the short lady. Especially the red sole of the louboutin heels, magic and sexy, many ladies are crazy. The red sole, the first feature of the Christian Louboutin stroe.

Unknown said...

Ankara'nın en güzel escortlarıyla görüşmek için çankaya escort sayfamızı ziyaret edebilirsiniz.

Tom Gonhound said...

Amazing article, i agree that feminism has been distorted by the current political climate and the media with small fringe groups getting disproportionate attention, their views are radical, but rapidly becomnig mainsteam and that's what is truly dangerous. Unfortunately so many people are unaware of it as many are also unaware of the place to get osrs gold cheapest

Pankaj Singh said...

Useful and interesting to read this article, I would like to thank you so much, for share this blog.
Jeans Supplier in Delhi

Just Info said...

I am goanna try that every time I post going forward. Thanks for your valuable knowledge because of this i use to updated, thanks for sharing this wonderful article.
logo painting on wall

Unknown said...

Amazing article and valuable information because of helpful for me, thank you so much for share this wonderful article.
Sea Freight Company in India

Mobile app development company in toronto said...

Thank You! For sharing such a great article, It’s been a amazing article.
It’s provide lot’s of information, I really enjoyed to read this.

Mobile app Development Company in Delhi said...

Nice and interesting post,I appreciate your hard work,keep uploading more, Thank you for sharing valuable information.

Chiến SEOCAM said...

Es difícil encontrar un artículo bueno y excelente como este artículo de anuncio. Deseo que toda la suerte te llegue.

lưới chống chuột

cửa lưới dạng xếp

cửa lưới tự cuốn

cửa lưới chống muỗi

Maketting SEO said...

Si el agua cae al lago, desaparecerá( phụ kiện tủ bếp ). Pero si cae a la hoja de( phụ kiện tủ áo ) loto, brillará como una joya. Caer igual pero( thùng gạo thông minh ) estar con alguien es importante.

The India said...

Bali Honeymoon Packages From Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Chennai
Hong Kong Packages From Delhi
Europe Packages from Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Mumbai
Maldives Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
travel company in Delhi
============================================================================

Cadencealida said...

You can fully trust the Path of Exile Trading Store poecurrency.com. Since its establishment, we have provided POE Currency trading and equipment trading services for tens of thousands of POE players. We satisfy all players with outstanding service quality. This is our proud cause, and we welcome you.

Cadencealida said...

ACBellsBuy launched a large number of promotional activities, Buy Nook Miles Tickets on ACBellsBuy. We have prepared rich gifts for you.

mmoTony2017 said...

IGGM is now the best online shop for players to buy cheap POE Currency, they have a professional team and fast delivery!

Anonymous said...

Really informative post, thanks for the post and effort! Keep sharing a lot of posts like this. Learn more about magento development.

wowclassicgold said...

I buy wow tbc gold from MMORPGMALL
always low price and fast delivery.
Wow Tbc Gold US

Wow Tbc Gold EU

WoW Classic TBC Level Boosting
New World Coins
New World Level Boosting

Mobile App Development Company in Bangalore said...

Thank you very nice sharing.