Tuesday, May 19, 2009

The Ol' College Try

President Obama deserves a great deal of credit for delivering the commencement address at Notre Dame, and Notre Dame deserves credit for inviting him. It is an example of the kind of civility that we have missed for the last eight years. (Full disclosure: my employer, Ohio State University, invited George Bush to commencement in June, 2002. After students and family filed into the stadium for the event, the stadium was put under lock-down and student protesters were arrested. Several spent up to 72 hours in jail for carrying signs or for turning their backs on Bush when he spoke).

The President addressed the issue that made his appearence controversial head-on: abortion rights. By drawing an analogy to the issue of civil rights in the 1950s, he suggested that people could find common ground on this thorny question.

On one level, the President simply acknowledged what has been true already in this country for about a generation. In survey after survey, a majority of Americans support access to abortion, though most favor certain kinds of restriction on that access. A majority of Americans, in other words, have already reached that common ground, though we haven't quite had the courage yet to admit this fully and out loud.

But at another level, of course, the President searched for a middle ground in vain. For those - and as it turns out there weren't really that many of them - who turned out to protest Obama's speech, abortion can only be discussed in absolutist terms. Any abortion under any circumstance ought to be criminalized. No quarter given; no half-way measures. We might dismiss these people as a small minority of zealots except for the fact that they exercise of outsized influence on our politics, and indeed, on the culture as a whole. The multi-millionaire founder of Dominos pizza, for example, has contributed heavily to anti-choice causes and the founder of Curves, the chain of women's gyms, posts on his website his desire to "destroy" Planned Parenthood.

This single-minded opposition to abortion masks other agendas, as many have pointed out. The issue, for some, isn't really about unborn children but about controlling women. The Catholic church, after all, is probably the world's largest institution predicated on the discrimination of women. For others, the fixation on fetuses is a proxy for an attack on sexuality more broadly. When the President suggested that we might find common ground by finding ways to reduce unwanted pregnancies, he did not mention Texas where high schoolers are only given abstinance education and which, surprise surprise, now has one of the highest rates of teen pregnancy in the nation.

Right as those explanations surely are, behind them looms a particular christian theology that we need to understand. For fundamentalist Protestants and their Catholic allies, the important lesson of the Gospels did not come from the Sermon on the Mount, but from the events on Calvary. They aren't interested in messages of compassion, love, of lasts being first, but rather in the passion and the crucifixion. (Remember fundamentalist Catholic Mel Gibson's bizarre movie which some dubbed "The Jesus Chain Saw Massacre??) In this view of the world, suffering and pain are the only roads to redemption.

At its root, the fetish of the fetus isn't about the "sanctity of life" but rather about the importance of suffering. Carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term, therefore, offers an opportunity for that redemptive suffering. And since the goal of these fundamentalists is that we all be saved according to their formula, forcing women to have these babies makes perfect sense.

Perhaps a better way to understand the theology of anti-choice fundamentalism is remember the circus that erupted during the Terry Schiavo fiasco. The very same crowd the pickets in front of Planned Parenthood turned their energy and resources to keeping the vegetative Schiavo alive not despite the fact that she would never recover, but precisely because she never would. She suffered; her husband suffered; it was all good for them.

And if those protesters who greeted President Obama in South Bend have their way, we'd all suffer too.


John said...

We would like to nominate you for a FreedomToBlog.com Best of Blog Entry.

Please visit our site at: http://www.freedomtoblog.com to submit your blog entry!

Benefits include:
1) Permanent Backlinks to your blog
2) Fully SEO optimized for maximum exposure
3) A chance to be published into a top 500 best of blog book"

Scott said...

Clearly the author doesn't know much about Catholicism. The issue isn't about controlling women or redemptive suffering, it is about the sanctity of life. If you want a religion that is about controlling women, just look to Islam.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing this topics as good as ones about
jordan shoes, everyone has his perspetives about air jordan shoes, some online stores bigtimekicks.com, dragonkicks.com, kicksexpress.com of
air jordans have all the best images and stories about nike air jordans. Feel free to use it anytime. it is full of passion. If you would like to suggest a good source of Discount Electronics, please share it with me.

best dissertation said...

I have been visiting various blogs for my dissertation research. I have found your blog to be quite useful. Keep updating your blog with valuable information... Regards

Dissertation Writing service said...

Despite the bulk of information online we often fail to get the specific information which is needed this post is good & contains relevant information that I was in quest of .I appreciate your efforts in preparing this post.

Dissertation writing

Microsoft Office 2007 said...

Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Microsoft word
Office 2007
Microsoft Office
Microsoft Office 2007
Office 2007 key
Office 2007 download
Office 2007 Professional
Outlook 2010
Microsoft outlook
Microsoft outlook 2010
Windows 7

Dissertation Help said...

wow, very nice blog. i like it.

[url=http://www.dissertationhelpindia.com]Dissertation Help[/url]

bed dissertations for sale said...

This is not a cost-saving initiative by any stretch,” says Sundt. While critics often disparage online education for being just another belt-tightening measure, USC has actually hired more teachers since the launch of the online program, and the cost for students is the same. For a campus tight on space, the benefit is that those students don’t take up any more physical room.


dissertation writers uk

dissertation writers uk

Dissertation Writers


Dissertation Topics

Dissertation Topics

Marketing Dissertation Topics

How to write a dissertation proposal said...

I have been slowly filling the keel back up after fixing the leak. I have used the original lead blocks, and instead of concrete and foam, I used polyester resin, with 3/4" crushed rock road gravel added. This should make it impossible for it to leak, or rather, any leak would be through just a crack, rather than a split.
This construction will give structural support to both sides of the centreboard trunk.
I will finish it off with a layer of woven matt, to make like a false floor.

How to Write a Dissertation Proposal

Research Proposal Writers

Write my Research Proposal uk

UK Research Proposal Writers

Research Paper Writers

Free research proposals

Finance research proposal

research proposal Dissertation Topics

Mphil Dissertations said...

Human behaviour is such that we all – each of us – love to tell ourselves we’re worth more than we really are. At least, for our work. Just browse any portfolio and you’ll notice designers talking about how good they are at design (despite the fact they kind of lack any sense of brand or identity), or they list reams of items under “skills” ranging from their abilities with Adobe Photoshop (the relevant) to their knowledge of antiquated HTML versions (the mundane) to what mouse they use (the asinine). Truth be told, if you’ve worked hard to earn a degree, and spent your money on the course, then you have a strong tendency to tell everyone about it.

dissertation assistance

essay editing

thesis proofreading

writing proposals

essay writing

essay writers

writing services

essay service

Marketing Dissertations Help said...

he good people at WZZM13 were nice enough to update us all tonight on the current state of unemployment here in the great state of Michigan. Yes, Virginia, it's true, we've officially topped the national list AGAIN. The current national average is 4.6%, w


dissertation writer uk

essay writer

how to write a proposal


writing papers

writing help

dissertation help/

Dissertation Help India said...

A demand for urban living is helping Cleveland’s downtown achieve something like vibrancy. Whether it reaches its promise will depend on whether or not we can find people enough places to live.

Dissertation Help

Dissertation Topics

Dissertation writers from india

uk dissertations

spss dissertation help

dissertation india

dissertation samples

dissertation help india</

Human Resource Dissertation Help said...

Last month NBC decided to give Community a half season, meaning it's not coming back after Christmas. To protest their horrible decision fans have been tuning in to spike the ratings and save their show!

Human Resource

Dissertation Help

Human Resource Dissertation


Human Resource Dissertation


HR dissertations

Human Resource Thesis


dissertation india

dissertation samples

dissertation help


Online Marketing Dissertation said...

A few pages ago Jamie found her pipe wrench… this is where she gets her first gun of the series. You better believe that she’ll put both to good use!

Online Dissertation Help

Online Dissertation Topics

Online Dissertation writers

Online Marketing dissertations

Online Thesis help

dissertation india

india dissertations

dissertation help india

ecommerce dissertation help said...

Last month NBC decided to give Community a half season, meaning it's not coming back after Christmas. To protest their horrible decision fans have been tuning in to spike the ratings and save their show!


dissertation help

Information Technology


IT Dissertation

internet security


ecommerce Thesis






dissertation help


ecommerce thesis help said...

On Wednesday afternoon, Microsoft’s Frank Shaw announced in a blog post that 2012 would be Microsoft’s last year at CES. Next year, the company won’t be hosting a booth (well, it’s been more like an all-consuming Microsoft pavilion), and its run of 14 straight keynote addresses will be over.


dissertation help


Technology Dissertation



internet security


ecommerce Thesis






dissertation help


undergraduate dissertation said...

I was looking for this certain info for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

flywowgoldkylin said...

Save On Jordan Shoes Retro Vii Jordan Shoes Retro Vii. Compare
Jordan shoes
Jordan kicks
basketball shoes
cheap shoes
Jordan 11