Wednesday, November 4, 2009

The impossible contradiction that is the Democratic president




It took almost a year, but we now are hearing the conservative critique of Obama that he "dithers," that he waffles, that he wavers, that he is not quite a real man because he does not show convictions. Of course, we've heard the "waffle" epithet thrown at other Democratic presidents, especially Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter. And you don't have to be Democratic president to be called a dithering, waffling unmanly man. Just ask John Kerry.

What is remarkable about these charges is not that they are made: critics know we want a strong leader (that phrase is almost redundant). What is remarkable is that the charge is made at the same time as the opposite charge: that Obama (or fill in the name of a Democratic presidential candidate) is a megalomaniac bent on using the government to fulfill--you guessed it--his horrifying liberal convictions. In other words, Obama is a waffle with a fascist's mustache.

One of these may be true. He may be the waffle or the mustache. But not both.

To be fair, conservatives have had to deal with Republican presidents facing their own familiar from the Left: that they are stupid. Now they are even facing social scientists who try to prove it. George W. Bush faced this charge throughout his presidency, but so did Reagan. Republican vice presidents have faced it (remember Dan Quayle) and of course Republican vice presidential candidates (Sarah Palin). At the same time, liberals have painted Republican presidents, despite their supposed stupidity, as scheming to destroy all that is good. The threat is real enough to earn them the fascist mustache on protesters' placards. The contradiction here is slightly less pronounced, because liberals can point to a Rasputin-like team of advisers who tell the supposedly-dumb president what to do (that logic works less well for Republicans attacking a Democrat because the Democratic president would not waffle if they had an analogous team of scheming liberal advisers).

While there may be a grain of truth to these stereotypes (that Democratic presidents are more deliberate and Republican presidents more un-nuanced in their assessments of issues), the media are probably responding to what psychologists have identified as a kind of cognitive confirmation bias: we start with a meaning of a thing, and then we notice everything that conforms to that meaning, and ignore that which does not. We can hold only one meaning of a thing at a time (either waffler *or* liberal schemer), and bias our interpretations based on that.

9 comments:

常法 said...

Gods mill grinds slow but sure........................................

Leanne said...

Catching up on my reading and I have to say, the phrase "Obama is a waffle with a fascist's mustache" gave me a laugh at a moment when I really needed one. Thanks.

And yes... nice post.

mitchellattwood said...

happy to read~ thank you!..................................................

小湘 said...

人必須心懷希望,才會活的快樂,日子才過得充實,有意義,有朝氣,有信心。........................................

wsxwhx677 said...

柔情聊天室 -
玩美女人影音秀 mv -
aio交友愛情公寓館 -
免費下載a片 -
小褲褲ㄉ誘惑 -
美乳淫娃網 -
365色情電影下載網 -
洪爺影城 -
情人視訊樂園視訊聊天交友 -
免費美國棒球線上直播 -
色美媚部落格2站 -
丁字褲美女 -
日本色情網站 -
超G名模影音視訊聊天室 -
3cc流行音樂網 -
閃亮天使520聊天室 -
電話交友 -
美女寫真圖片區 -
愛戀中華美眉-交友中心 -
台灣無限貼圖區 -
後宮電影城 -
免費情色小電影 -
LIVE173影音視訊live秀-一對一免費視訊 -
包月視訊美女 -
一葉情貼圖片區 -
視訊辣妹影片直播 -
免費av18禁 -
情影片線上免費看 -
鐘點情人影音聊天室 -
美媚寫真104 -
小杜倩色文學 -
美女視訊免費看 -
脫衣辣妹部落格 -
學生妹自拍照 -
偏愛熟女人妻館 -
免費視訊辣妹 -
校園美女影音視訊網 -
波波情色貼圖 -
免費情色影片 -
休閒小站自拍寫真 -

miss said...

我從來不認為不同意我的看法就是冒犯..............................

Viagra Online said...

Greetings Tom S and blogger folks!
I just dropped by in order to let you know what I think about this affair.
In fact, I am glad to know that it isn't only I but you too, who are interested in such a concerning issue as this one is.
I respectfully admire you due to your pretty well done piece of column.
Regards

Microsoft Office 2007 said...

Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Microsoft word
Office 2007
Microsoft Office
Microsoft Office 2007
Office 2007 key
Office 2007 download
Office 2007 Professional
Outlook 2010
Microsoft outlook
Microsoft outlook 2010
Windows 7

linad said...

Very good share ~ message support
............................................................